Food & Beverage Litigation & Regulatory Update

Category: U.S. Circuit Courts

  • Court Recognizes Severe Obesity as Disability Under ADA

    Denying an employer’s motions for summary judgment in an employment discrimination suit, a federal court in Louisiana has determined that severe obesity, regardless of its basis, qualifies as a disability under the Americans with Disabilities Act. EEOC v. Res. for Human Dev., Inc., No. 10-03322 (E.D. La., decided December 7, 2011). The court did not…

  • McDonald’s Sidesteps San Francisco Toy Ban, Will Appeal $1.8 Million Brazilian Fine

    McDonald’s Corp. has reportedly responded to a San Francisco ban on giving away toys with its Happy Meals® by allowing parents to purchase the toys with a 10-cent charitable contribution when they buy a Happy Meal®. While the toy purchase is purportedly a separate transaction that complies with the new ordinance, it will still require…

  • Court Dismisses Challenge to OEHHA’s Listing of 4-MEI as Carcinogen Under Prop. 65

    A California court has determined that California EPA’s Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA) complied with the law in determining that 4-methylimidazole (4-MEI), a chemical present in many common foods and beverages, is a carcinogen known to the state to cause cancer. Cal. League of Food Processors v. OEHHA, No. 34-2011-80000784 (Cal. Super. Ct.,…

  • Putative Class Contends One-Cup Coffee Cartridges Are Not Fresh Ground

    A New Mexico resident has filed a putative statewide class action in federal court claiming that a company which makes one-cup coffee cartridges for Keurig® single-serve coffee machines falsely labels and markets its cartridges as fresh coffee when they are actually filled with instant coffee. Bracewell v. Sturm Foods, Inc., No. 11-01024 (D.N.M., filed November…

  • Contaminated Cantaloupe Plaintiff Sues Food Safety Auditor and Others

    A Nebraska resident alleging that his consumption of Listeria-contaminated cantaloupe grown by Jensen Farms in Colorado caused his infection and subsequent hospitalization, has filed a personal injury action against the grower, distributor, retailer, and the company hired by the grower to conduct a food safety audit before the outbreak. Braddock v. Jensen Farms, No. 11-402…

  • Class Definition in Yo-Plus® Litigation Redefined on Remand

    A federal court in Florida has redefined a plaintiffs’ class in deceptive advertising litigation against the company that claims its Yo-Plus® yogurt provides digestive health benefits. Fitzpatrick v. General Mills, Inc., No. 09-60412 (S.D. Fla., order entered December 2, 2011). While the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the class certification decision, it remanded the…

  • Ferrero Settles with California Plaintiffs in Nutella® False Advertising Class Action

    According to a news source, the company that makes the hazelnut spread Nutella®, which is advertised as part of a healthy breakfast for children, has reached a settlement in the class action certified by a federal court in California last month. In re Ferrero Litig., No. 11-205 (S.D. Cal., minute entry November 28, 2011). A…

  • Pom Wonderful Loses Deceptive Claim Lawsuit Against Ocean Spray

    According to a news source, Pom Wonderful LLC, which was seeking $18.1 million in lost sales from Ocean Spray Cranberries Inc. for falsely selling a pomegranate juice product with just trace amounts of pomegranate juice, lost its case following less than two hours’ deliberation by a federal jury. Pom Wonderful LLC V. Ocean Spray Cranberries…